Oil Can or Black Nickel?

I currently have a Vokey Raw 56 degree SW and I have a set of Cleveland TA-5 Irons and as most of you know there is a pretty large gap in between my PW and SW so i am going to get a Titleist 52 degree GW but the big question is which style should i get?

Right now the Black Nickel looks closer to the Raw model i have but i heard that the Oil Can is supposed to rust and eventually look like the Raw.. is this right? and which one would you get and why?

oil can is really nice, good spin, nice club. a titleist original, go with the oil can.

[QUOTE=bethpage caddy]oil can is really nice, good spin, nice club. a titleist original, go with the oil can.[/QUOTE]


I have a black nickel gap, 252.08. I also have a oilcan lob 260.08. I think the nickel is better for a gap wedge, the finish looks closer to my irons and i find visually that is more appealing. its an awful finish for a sand or lob wedge though as it is very prone to scratching when hit from sand, and i had to return the nickel lob wedge and swap it for a oilcan. Feel wise there is nothing in it. I just feel the nickel frames the ball better on longer shots.

Nothing beats an oil can. It is a great wedge and spins a ton.

[QUOTE=Ed "White Shoes" Rooney]Nothing beats an oil can. It is a great wedge and spins a ton.[/QUOTE]

Clevelands do.

Thanks for the input... i ended up buying the Oil Can